What’s more American than potato salad? At least my mom’s recipe is, which is a 50s/early 60s paean to the wonders of that ultimate convenience food, Miracle Whip. I’m sure you could substitute mayonnaise if you, like my husband, hate Miracle Whip (What’s the difference? See here. If you google, you’ll find lots of evidence of mixed marriages like mine). To me–and to the family members who ask me to make it–it tastes like summer in its purest form.
Cheryl’s Potato Salad
One of the things I love about this recipe is that it instantly converts to the quantity needed. For each person, you’ll need one potato (I usually use russets), one egg, one scallion (my mom always called these green onions – did they change the name?), and one sweet gherkin.
Prep:
Hard boil the eggs. Cut into small (1/4 – 1/2″) chunks. Don’t worry about the yolks and whites separating out.
Peel and cut the potatoes (I cut medium-sized potatoes into quarters, more chunks for larger – the important thing is that the size be consistent and not too big), and boil until pierce-able with a fork but not mushy. Drain and cool. Then cut into roughly 3/4″ chunks.
Slice the scallions thinly (white parts only). Likewise the gherkins.
Put it together:
In a bowl, combine potatoes, scallions and gherkins. For each person, add one heaping soup spoon of Miracle Whip (more or less – you might want to add less the first time you make it and adjust up). Then add 1/2 teaspoon mustard for each person. I use good ol’ bright yellow French’s or the like.
Stir until almost combined. Then add eggs and stir a bit more. You want it to be well-combined but the potatoes should still be chunky. Add salt and pepper to taste. Cover and refrigerate until serving time – several hours at least, if you like it really cold like I do.
True confession: I’ve been known to eat a bowl for breakfast.